ShoreTel Investor Day 2012 - Implications for UC
I was fortunate to be one of a few industry analysts invited to attend this week's landmark update from ShoreTel to the financial analyst community in their hometown of San Francisco. Joining me from the UCStrategies group was Blair Pleasant and Stephen Leaden, and if you followed our tweets, you already know the gist of what was discussed.
Both Stephen and I have already written lengthy posts about their recent acquisition of M5 Networks, and I'll spare you the public details here. I'd rather focus on what's new and my key takeaways for UC. Some of these have already been anticipated and discussed here on UCS, but this was the first opportunity for anyone in the analyst communities - both industry and financial - to have direct, in-person dialog with the management teams of these companies in one place. I found this a pretty unique confluence of events and was quite happy to be there.
We heard a lot of validation about the momentum behind the cloud and how well ShoreTel is holding its own in the very competitive IP telephony market. Cisco and Avaya remain dominant, but the gap between Avaya and the #3 players is shrinking, and depending on who you talk to, it's either ShoreTel or Mitel. I don't think it matters who's #3 here, as I think most people would say ShoreTel is faring better, and is perhaps positioned the best of all these vendors for what's driving the market today.
I wouldn't be saying that without M5 being in the picture, as this now gives ShoreTel a play on both sides of the fence - premise-based or cloud - and could prove to be the best model as everyone struggles to figure out where cloud is taking things (as Kevin Gavin said, "we can say yes to both"). So, what makes M5 so special? As CEO Dan Hoffman noted, their business is like real estate, with three key drivers - "reliability, reliability, reliability". Unlike most hosted/cloud providers, they run VoIP over secure, private networks, and perform best with MPLS-enabled customers. This gives them a leg up on most competitors for the most fundamental characteristic of a voice service, as many offerings run over the public Internet, where QoS is difficult to apply at best.
Building off that base, they understand the voice 2.0 value proposition - it's all about the applications and the experience - not just cheaper, reliable connectivity. With VoIP, dial tone quickly becomes a commodity, and their view is that high value applications are the best way to differentiate against low priced competitors. One example was their Live Answer demo - a simple cloud-based diagnostic tool that shows what percentage of calls is being answered live. This basic piece of information has inherent value not just in the contact center, but for any business where phone inquiries can lead to sales.
Another example is how they have embedded Salesforce.com into their voice service, enabling employees to have to full visibility to a customer's history during a call - again, either for contact center agents or front of the house staff. This is exactly the type of integration UC touts, but M5 doesn't really talk about this as UC. They take a different approach to voice with the cloud. For M5, the value of their service is not the call itself or their ability to deliver business-grade dial tone. The real value comes from the information wrapped around that call, and with all the intelligence and horsepower in the cloud, they can provide so much more to the business.
I think this is a big part of what ShoreTel sees in M5, who is not really in the business of providing lower cost hosted telephony. From the beginning, they've focused on how information can be added to voice to address specific business challenges. As they build a track record of the aforementioned reliable service, they earn the all-important trusted partner status with customers. This puts them in a great position to offer not just enhanced features like FM-FM, but higher value capabilities that actually require technical expertise, such as conferencing, mobility, voice recording, transcription, etc.
This is starting to sound a bit more like UC now, right? I think so, but we didn't hear too many references to UC during the presentations. They're definitely going in the same direction as UC, and trying to address the same types of problems. Both companies talked about the ascendancy of mobility, and it almost feels inevitable that in time, a smartphone will be the only device we use. ShoreTel may have a nice core of premise-based customers, but they're following the puck, both in terms of upping their mobile game and getting religion on cloud. They'll be the first to tell you their future does not lie in selling IP desk phones.
On that note, ShoreTel's Pejman Roshan gave a compelling demo of how well they can extend 4 digit PBX calling to an iPhone. More importantly, he showed how much better it worked compared to Cisco and Jabber, which could not route the call past the cellular network and into the corporate network. Combining this with M5's cloud service over a private network, they can offer all their customers high value mobile integration.
Both companies know that smartphones are driving the big growth in communications, and that value lies in the applications. By mining the information around calls in the cloud, they can identify new opportunities for applications, not just with mobile devices, but how they integrate with the other devices and screens used throughout the business.
My main takeaway from all this is that both companies have a good handle on how to create and deliver value to customers. I've talked previously about how the recurring revenue model of M5's business will drive sustainable profitability for ShoreTel, and we heard more detail about that during the presentations.
Overall, I'd say there's a good mix here of meat and potatoes IP telephony along with enough advanced applications to keep them on the right side of the innovation curve for the foreseeable future. We hardly heard anything about emerging trends like video or social media, but I don't think that hurts them. These opportunities today are too disruptive for their core markets, and given that they've refined a recipe for success with everything else, they can afford to add those pieces when the business models mature a bit more.
To be fair, UC was discussed, mostly during the customer panel, so it is in their thinking. However, I don't think most businesses or channel partners would call either company UC providers. Also, ShoreTel has bigger issues in terms of folding M5 into their operations - the business, their people, their customers and their brand - and I don't think the UC moniker is keeping them up at night.
These are very practical companies, and both are successful because they've learned how to listen to what customers want and from there, develop a solution that adds value. So much of what they're doing is UC in our eyes, but that's not what customers are typically asking for. I think that will change as the UC concept takes root with businesses and end users. A lot of businesses are still just weaning themselves off of TDM, so we have to be realistic about how fast these changes will come - at least among the core customer set ShoreTel and M5 are serving. For now, I think we should just be happy things have come this far - we know it's UC. As long as the customer is buying, does it really matter what they call it? I think I know what Peter Blackmore and Dan Hoffman would say about that.
Tags
Start YourCustomized Search
SOLUTION AREA
SOLUTION PROVIDERS
- 8x8 (40) Apply 8x8 filter
- Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise (50) Apply Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise filter
- AT&T (44) Apply AT&T filter
- AudioCodes (49) Apply AudioCodes filter
- Avaya (397) Apply Avaya filter
- Cisco (574) Apply Cisco filter
- Dell (11) Apply Dell filter
- Five9 (54) Apply Five9 filter
- Fuze (39) Apply Fuze filter
- Genesys (100) Apply Genesys filter
- HP (98) Apply HP filter
- IBM (171) Apply IBM filter
- Jabra (9) Apply Jabra filter
- Logitech (56) Apply Logitech filter
- Lumen (4) Apply Lumen filter
- Masergy (50) Apply Masergy filter
- Microsoft (766) Apply Microsoft filter
- Mitel (233) Apply Mitel filter
- NEC (128) Apply NEC filter
- Nectar (58) Apply Nectar filter
- Polycom (95) Apply Polycom filter
- Ramp (37) Apply Ramp filter
- RingCentral (126) Apply RingCentral filter
- Sennheiser (18) Apply Sennheiser filter
- Slack (13) Apply Slack filter
- Tata Communications (59) Apply Tata Communications filter
- Unify (186) Apply Unify filter
- Vonage Business (80) Apply Vonage Business filter
- Yealink (8) Apply Yealink filter
- Zoom (21) Apply Zoom filter
- Acme Packet (24) Apply Acme Packet filter
- Allworx (2) Apply Allworx filter
- Arkadin (22) Apply Arkadin filter
- Aspect (34) Apply Aspect filter
- BT (25) Apply BT filter
- CaféX (8) Apply CaféX filter
- CallTower (14) Apply CallTower filter
- Clarity Connect (10) Apply Clarity Connect filter
- Continuant (1) Apply Continuant filter
- Damaka (4) Apply Damaka filter
- Dialogic (5) Apply Dialogic filter
- Dimension Data (44) Apply Dimension Data filter
- Empirix (11) Apply Empirix filter
- Enghouse Interactive (17) Apply Enghouse Interactive filter
- Inference Solutions (9) Apply Inference Solutions filter
- IntelePeer (27) Apply IntelePeer filter
- IR (11) Apply IR filter
- Jive (21) Apply Jive filter
- Kurmi Software (21) Apply Kurmi Software filter
- Lifesize (33) Apply Lifesize filter
- Lightware (3) Apply Lightware filter
- Mavenir (6) Apply Mavenir filter
- Modality Systems (8) Apply Modality Systems filter
- Momentum (36) Apply Momentum filter
- Netfortris (5) Apply Netfortris filter
- NetSapiens (6) Apply NetSapiens filter
- NewVoiceMedia (31) Apply NewVoiceMedia filter
- Nureva (26) Apply Nureva filter
- NUWAVE (5) Apply NUWAVE filter
- Orange (32) Apply Orange filter
- OVCC (8) Apply OVCC filter
- Panasonic (18) Apply Panasonic filter
- PanTerra Networks (9) Apply PanTerra Networks filter
- ScanSource (21) Apply ScanSource filter
- SIPPIO (3) Apply SIPPIO filter
- Snom (20) Apply Snom filter
- Star2Star (8) Apply Star2Star filter
- StarLeaf (12) Apply StarLeaf filter
- Tadiran Telecom (2) Apply Tadiran Telecom filter
- TekVizion (9) Apply TekVizion filter
- Unimax (7) Apply Unimax filter
- Verint (41) Apply Verint filter
- Voice4Net (2) Apply Voice4Net filter
- VOSS (85) Apply VOSS filter
- Voxbone (14) Apply Voxbone filter
- West (28) Apply West filter
- XO Communications (3) Apply XO Communications filter
- Yorktel (17) Apply Yorktel filter
- Zultys (2) Apply Zultys filter
- 3CX (8) Apply 3CX filter
- ADDASOUND (1) Apply ADDASOUND filter
- Aerohive (1) Apply Aerohive filter
- Aryaka (1) Apply Aryaka filter
- Asurion (22) Apply Asurion filter
- Avnet (7) Apply Avnet filter
- Bandwidth (5) Apply Bandwidth filter
- Calabrio (5) Apply Calabrio filter
- Consilium Software (13) Apply Consilium Software filter
- Drum (5) Apply Drum filter
- ESI (6) Apply ESI filter
- Esna (16) Apply Esna filter
- Exinda (2) Apply Exinda filter
- EZuce (3) Apply EZuce filter
- GUnify (6) Apply GUnify filter
- Highfive (4) Apply Highfive filter
- Huawei (47) Apply Huawei filter
- Imagicle (3) Apply Imagicle filter
- IPCortex (1) Apply IPCortex filter
- KnoahSoft (1) Apply KnoahSoft filter
- KOVA (1) Apply KOVA filter
- Logmein (9) Apply Logmein filter
- Metropolis Technologies (4) Apply Metropolis Technologies filter
- Mutare (2) Apply Mutare filter
- NextPlane (27) Apply NextPlane filter
- Ooma (16) Apply Ooma filter
- Patton (11) Apply Patton filter
- Radish Systems (1) Apply Radish Systems filter
- Radisys (3) Apply Radisys filter
- Shango (1) Apply Shango filter
- SMART (163) Apply SMART filter
- Stack8 (1) Apply Stack8 filter
- Swyx (1) Apply Swyx filter
- TrueConf (4) Apply TrueConf filter
- UJET (13) Apply UJET filter
- Voximplant (3) Apply Voximplant filter
CONTENT TYPE
- BC Expert Insights Market (43) Apply BC Expert Insights Market filter
- BC Expert Insights Objective - Vendor Neutral (42) Apply BC Expert Insights Objective - Vendor Neutral filter
- BC Expert Insights Planning (15) Apply BC Expert Insights Planning filter
- BC Expert Insights Solution (12) Apply BC Expert Insights Solution filter
- BC Expert Insights Vendor (80) Apply BC Expert Insights Vendor filter
- BC Expert Insights Vendor Solution (145) Apply BC Expert Insights Vendor Solution filter
- BC Expert Roundtable (133) Apply BC Expert Roundtable filter
- Bcs Webinar (0)
- Bcs Webinar Registration (0)
- Best Practice (38) Apply Best Practice filter
- Buyer Guide (14) Apply Buyer Guide filter
- Case Study (29) Apply Case Study filter
- Executive Interview (145) Apply Executive Interview filter
- Expert Roundtable (450) Apply Expert Roundtable filter
- Guest Contributions (35) Apply Guest Contributions filter
- Multimedia (38) Apply Multimedia filter
- News Analysis (2081) Apply News Analysis filter
- Newsfeed Article (1303) Apply Newsfeed Article filter
- Newsfeed Article (1) Apply Newsfeed Article filter
- Thought Leadership (21) Apply Thought Leadership filter
- Vendor Collateral (211) Apply Vendor Collateral filter
- Vendor Resource Best Practices (24) Apply Vendor Resource Best Practices filter
- Vendor Resource Buyers Guides (2) Apply Vendor Resource Buyers Guides filter
- Vendor Resource Multimedia Content (4) Apply Vendor Resource Multimedia Content filter
- Vendor Resource White Paper (4) Apply Vendor Resource White Paper filter
- Webinar (13) Apply Webinar filter
- Webinars (7) Apply Webinars filter
- White Paper (64) Apply White Paper filter
MORE FILTERS
INDUSTRY
- Banking And Investment (800) Apply Banking And Investment filter
- Education (446) Apply Education filter
- Energy And Utilities (487) Apply Energy And Utilities filter
- Finance (12) Apply Finance filter
- Government (675) Apply Government filter
- Healthcare (482) Apply Healthcare filter
- Hospitality (180) Apply Hospitality filter
- Insurance (100) Apply Insurance filter
- Manufacturing (704) Apply Manufacturing filter
- Media/Publishing (422) Apply Media/Publishing filter
- None (43) Apply None filter
- Professional Services (745) Apply Professional Services filter
- Retail & Distribution (798) Apply Retail & Distribution filter
- Technology (1611) Apply Technology filter
- Transportation (110) Apply Transportation filter
Comments
There are currently no comments on this article.
You must be a registered user to make comments