Anti-Collaboration Boards
“I believe whiteboards are an evil presence in meetings … Simply going to the board and picking up a pen changes the whole dynamic of meeting ownership, agenda, control and creates a power-dynamic that is pretty hostile to collaboration.” These are the words of Steven Sinofsky, prior president of the Windows division at Microsoft and current board member at Andreessen Horowitz.
Sinofsky admits they can be useful in certain types of brainstorming sessions, but generally advises to minimize or eliminate their use. He claims that in addition to being hostile to collaboration, whiteboards stifle participation of those unwilling to use them, and they amplify the ideas of those who do.
This advice seems in conflict with where the collaboration industry is headed – a new generation of e-whiteboards. Microsoft, Cisco, Zoom, and Google are among the vendors with a new generation of e-whiteboards that they claim improves productivity and collaboration.
I see the merits of both points of view, and have come to conclude that the two perspectives aren’t in conflict. Sinofsky is talking about actual (dumb) boards. The new variants on e-boards represent more than just a materials/format change – they represent a change in functionality.
The traditional whiteboard or chalkboard is a presentation surface effective for the sharing and documenting of concepts. It is, for the most part, a single-operator, line-of-sight, ephemeral device. Those limitations severely limit a board’s collaborative capabilities.
Old-school boards are relics of a different era. Today, we live, practice, and preach digital transformation. That’s why so many conference rooms are now equipped with a display device – to present and share digital content. More often than not, the whiteboard is the only analog component of a meeting. Some video conferencing solutions (Dolby, Cisco) have special software that can de-skew and enhance the image of a board in an attempt to drag them into present day.
Beyond the technologies, meetings themselves have evolved in two important ways. Modern meetings are more likely to include remote participants than before, and they are more likely to be collaborative.
Traditional whiteboards are not terribly useful to remote participants. Video conferencing solutions support screen sharing, but that’s more for presentation than ideation or collaboration.
Many of these new e-boards allow remote participants to contribute. That change democratizes the whiteboard – reducing the risk that someone will use it to hijack the meeting.
Conferencing solutions such as Webex Teams and Google Hangouts Meet even support a virtual whiteboard that can be used instead of or in conjunction with a physical e-board.
Not long ago, meetings were what happened between spurts of productive work. Today, meetings are increasingly where the work gets done. The e-board is one more tool to consider, and it has an important new feature: preservation. E-boards can save and share content, and when integrated into a team collaboration space an e-boards content becomes part of the persistent, shared conversation.
Sinofsky’s meetings were likely mostly with developers, and the shared content was probably keyboard-friendly. But many people have topics and ideas that cannot be easily conveyed with a keyboard. That’s precisely why free-hand drawing surfaces are in just about every conference room. A table, chair, and board are the core requirements of a meeting room – everything else (lights, phone, display, etc.) is optional.
Any meeting can be hijacked by an exuberant personality, but that’s no reason to cripple a meeting with ineffective tools. The modern e-board can be used to explain complex thoughts, to generate and organize ideas, and to preserve the evolution and outcomes of meetings. These uses can play an increasingly important role as meetings become more distributed and as touch screens replace keyboards on our devices.
Start YourCustomized Search
SOLUTION AREA
SOLUTION PROVIDERS
- 8x8 (3) Apply 8x8 filter
- Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise (5) Apply Alcatel-Lucent Enterprise filter
- AT&T (6) Apply AT&T filter
- AudioCodes (4) Apply AudioCodes filter
- Avaya (92) Apply Avaya filter
- Cisco (109) Apply Cisco filter
- Dell (5) Apply Dell filter
- Five9 (5) Apply Five9 filter
- Fuze (5) Apply Fuze filter
- Genesys (16) Apply Genesys filter
- HP (12) Apply HP filter
- IBM (38) Apply IBM filter
- Jabra (1) Apply Jabra filter
- Logitech (24) Apply Logitech filter
- Masergy (38) Apply Masergy filter
- Microsoft (155) Apply Microsoft filter
- Mitel (44) Apply Mitel filter
- NEC (28) Apply NEC filter
- Nectar (14) Apply Nectar filter
- Polycom (16) Apply Polycom filter
- Ramp (37) Apply Ramp filter
- RingCentral (55) Apply RingCentral filter
- Sennheiser (4) Apply Sennheiser filter
- Slack (3) Apply Slack filter
- Tata Communications (43) Apply Tata Communications filter
- Unify (24) Apply Unify filter
- Vonage Business (15) Apply Vonage Business filter
- Yealink (1) Apply Yealink filter
- Acme Packet (2) Apply Acme Packet filter
- Arkadin (2) Apply Arkadin filter
- Aspect (16) Apply Aspect filter
- BT (11) Apply BT filter
- CallTower (10) Apply CallTower filter
- Clarity Connect (1) Apply Clarity Connect filter
- Dimension Data (3) Apply Dimension Data filter
- Empirix (5) Apply Empirix filter
- Enghouse Interactive (1) Apply Enghouse Interactive filter
- IntelePeer (10) Apply IntelePeer filter
- IR (5) Apply IR filter
- Jive (4) Apply Jive filter
- Lifesize (6) Apply Lifesize filter
- Mavenir (3) Apply Mavenir filter
- Momentum (32) Apply Momentum filter
- NewVoiceMedia (8) Apply NewVoiceMedia filter
- Nureva (20) Apply Nureva filter
- NUWAVE (1) Apply NUWAVE filter
- Orange (27) Apply Orange filter
- Panasonic (11) Apply Panasonic filter
- ScanSource (7) Apply ScanSource filter
- StarLeaf (1) Apply StarLeaf filter
- Tadiran Telecom (1) Apply Tadiran Telecom filter
- TekVizion (1) Apply TekVizion filter
- Verint (2) Apply Verint filter
- VOSS (3) Apply VOSS filter
- Voxbone (6) Apply Voxbone filter
- West (25) Apply West filter
- XO Communications (1) Apply XO Communications filter
- Yorktel (3) Apply Yorktel filter
- ADDASOUND (1) Apply ADDASOUND filter
- Asurion (3) Apply Asurion filter
- Avnet (2) Apply Avnet filter
- Bandwidth (4) Apply Bandwidth filter
- Drum (1) Apply Drum filter
- ESI (1) Apply ESI filter
- Highfive (1) Apply Highfive filter
- Huawei (28) Apply Huawei filter
- Logmein (2) Apply Logmein filter
- Mutare (1) Apply Mutare filter
- Ooma (8) Apply Ooma filter
- SMART (144) Apply SMART filter
- Voximplant (2) Apply Voximplant filter
CONTENT TYPE
- BC Expert Insights Market (3) Apply BC Expert Insights Market filter
- BC Expert Insights Objective - Vendor Neutral (6) Apply BC Expert Insights Objective - Vendor Neutral filter
- BC Expert Insights Planning (1) Apply BC Expert Insights Planning filter
- BC Expert Insights Solution (3) Apply BC Expert Insights Solution filter
- BC Expert Insights Vendor (22) Apply BC Expert Insights Vendor filter
- BC Expert Insights Vendor Solution (22) Apply BC Expert Insights Vendor Solution filter
- BC Expert Roundtable (0)
- Bcs Webinar (0)
- Bcs Webinar Registration (0)
- Best Practice (14) Apply Best Practice filter
- Buyer Guide (9) Apply Buyer Guide filter
- Case Study (24) Apply Case Study filter
- Executive Interview (26) Apply Executive Interview filter
- Expert Roundtable (9) Apply Expert Roundtable filter
- Guest Contributions (6) Apply Guest Contributions filter
- Multimedia (27) Apply Multimedia filter
- News Analysis (121) Apply News Analysis filter
- Newsfeed Article (0)
- Newsfeed Article (1087) Apply Newsfeed Article filter
- Thought Leadership (0)
- Vendor Collateral (162) Apply Vendor Collateral filter
- Vendor Resource Best Practices (3) Apply Vendor Resource Best Practices filter
- Vendor Resource Buyers Guides (2) Apply Vendor Resource Buyers Guides filter
- Vendor Resource Multimedia Content (4) Apply Vendor Resource Multimedia Content filter
- Vendor Resource White Paper (1) Apply Vendor Resource White Paper filter
- Webinar (2) Apply Webinar filter
- Webinars (0)
- White Paper (34) Apply White Paper filter
MORE FILTERS
INDUSTRY
- Banking And Investment (800) Apply Banking And Investment filter
- Education (446) Apply Education filter
- Energy And Utilities (487) Apply Energy And Utilities filter
- Finance (12) Apply Finance filter
- Government (675) Apply Government filter
- Healthcare (482) Apply Healthcare filter
- Hospitality (180) Apply Hospitality filter
- Insurance (100) Apply Insurance filter
- Manufacturing (704) Apply Manufacturing filter
- Media/Publishing (422) Apply Media/Publishing filter
- None (43) Apply None filter
- Professional Services (745) Apply Professional Services filter
- Retail & Distribution (798) Apply Retail & Distribution filter
- (-) Remove Technology filter Technology
- Transportation (110) Apply Transportation filter
Comments
There are currently no comments on this article.
You must be a registered user to make comments
Add new comment